Ludic Language Pedagogy Open Peer Review Guide

Dear reviewers,

Our driving philosophy/slogan for the open-peer review (OPR) process is:

By this, we mean that all communication should, where possible, occur on the submitted manuscript itself.

OPRing an LLP Google Document Submission

Initial review

  1. Use comments directly on the manuscript to:
  • Ask questions
  • Make suggestions
  • Give praise
  1. Complete a formal review at the end of the manuscript
  • โœ… Complete the reviewer form.
  • โœ… Complete the box โ€œInitial Recommendation.โ€
  • โœ… Complete the box โ€œReview Stage.โ€
  • โœ… Message the custom slack channel when the steps have been completed.

Revision stage

  • โœ… Check and resolve the authors revisions (as suggestions in GDocs).
  • โœ… Resolve any of your comments that have been addressed by the author.
  • โœ… Once all your comments are closed, complete the โ€œRevised Manuscript Recommendationโ€ section.
  • โœ… Message the custom slack channel when the steps have been completed.